Looking for Halloween costume inspo, but don’t want to break the bank on something new (or worse, show up to the Halloween party in the exact same costume as your worst frenemy)? A little DIY spell-casting can go a long way! Get more BOO! for your buck when you shop secondhand for those costume essentials. Scroll to find some spook-tacularly easy Halloween costumes to DIY at the thrift!
Through the Decades
In the market for a costume that hearkens back to a simpler time? Better call Marty McFly! An ensemble inspired by your favorite decade is one of the easiest Halloween costumes to DIY. Simply head to your favorite thrift store to browse retro and vintage finds or statement accessories that you can combine with everyday items you already have in your closet. A simple black dress and a few key accessories could quickly turn into Holly Golightly from Breakfast at Tiffany’s.
Undead & Unstoppable
Feeling sluggish or out of sorts this year? Perhaps an undead character would suit your mood. Whether you plan to go as a skeleton, vampire, or Corpse Bride, look for everyday items to layer with statement accessories and keep an eye out for lighter-colored pieces if you plan on adding a splash of fake blood or dirt.
Horror Icons
Everyone loves a good cult classic, especially if you’re a fan of things that go BUMP in the night! To nail your favorite horror icon look, focus on the most recognizable features. For the Bride of Frankenstein, it’s her voluminous hair and long white dress. For Lydia Deetz from Beetlejuice, it’s her black veil, wide brim hat and film camera. Need help bringing your vision to life? Stop by Buffalo Exchange for help styling the costume of your dreams (or should we say nightmares?)!
Clowncore Galore
Clowns don’t have to be creepy! Unless you want them to be, of course. At your local secondhand or thrift store, look for polka dots, bold stripes, ruffles/collars, tights and bright shoes. Clowns come in a variety of shapes, colors and silhouettes, so get out there and have fun with it! For a little extra flair, try adding bows, ruffles or a hat. This is one of the most maximalist Halloween costumes to DIY, so keep in mind that, in this case, more is more!
The Coziest Halloween Costumes to DIY
Who says Halloween has to be spooky? Embrace the cozy side of the season by dressing as a character that brings back all the nostalgia. Whether it’s an homage to children’s show characters that makes you feel right at home, that beloved cartoon from your favorite video game or a character from a series you’ve binged a dozen times like Gilmore Girls, these looks are all about comfort and joy. Look for iconic colors, playful patterns and distinct silhouettes to bring your favorite friend to life.
Giddyup, Partner!
Cowboys/cowgirls are easily customizable halloween costumes to DIY at the thrift. With a hat, boots and a button up shirt or vest, you can pull off a convincing Western look. Spice it up with accessories like oversized belt buckles and bolo ties, then throw on your favorite pair of jeans and you’re set. The best part? These are great staples to have in your closet year-round.
Fantasy & Folklore
Ready to channel your inner magical being? Whether you’re dreaming of Ren Faire vibes, enchanting fairies, wise wizards or even a journey through Middle-earth, the fantasy world is ripe for DIY-ing. Head to your local thrift store and look for flowy fabrics, lace-up details, capes, wings and earthy tones. Don’t be afraid to mix and match textures to create your own unique realm. From crowns to staffs, the right accessories will truly transport your look to another dimension.
Well there you have it, folks. When it comes to what kind of Halloween costumes to DIY at the thrift, the list is endless. Whether you’re looking to cast a spell or give someone the creepy crawlies, Buffalo Exchange has a curated selection of Halloween pieces that you can mix with everyday items for a scarily sustainable look. Plus, their costume stylists are available all throughout October to help you build your look from the ground up! Even better, bring in your cleanout and trade in last year’s costume along with all the other skeletons hanging around in your closet for cash or trade to use on this year’s costume. Ready to sell? Find your location & save time by hopping in line!
